Home  /  Journal  /  9 washers tested. 1 ships.

—Journal

9 washers tested. 1 ships.

Before we sold a single Tide, we lived with nine of its competitors for six weeks in our 320 sqft Brooklyn studio. We bought every mini washer with at least 100 reviews on Amazon and major direct sites — paid retail, no relationships disclosed to sellers, no PR samples.

Three leaked. Two died at cycle 30. One sounded like a jet at 80 dB. Here's the rundown — anonymous because we still respect the people who built them, and the goal isn't a takedown.

The protocol

Every washer ran the same 9-load weekly cycle for 6 weeks (54 cycles). The 9 loads:

  • 3 × everyday clothes (cotton tees, jeans, socks)
  • 2 × towels (medium, gym)
  • 2 × bedding (queen sheet sets)
  • 1 × delicates (mesh bag, bras, hosiery)
  • 1 × heavy (hoodie, sweatpants, towel)

We logged at every cycle: time to fill, wash duration, spin RPM (laser tach), drain time, noise (decibel meter at 3 ft), water temp, leak presence, smell. We weighed clothes wet and after spin to compute % water removed.

Round-by-round

FAIL · Week 1
Unit A — leaked at the gasket on cycle 4. Returned. The seller's reply was "did you overload?" We did not.
FAIL · Week 1
Unit B — strong plastic smell from cycle 1. Persisted after 5 empty rinse cycles. Returned.
FAIL · Week 2
Unit C — 78 dB during spin. Neighbor below knocked twice. Returned.
FAIL · Week 4
Unit D — motor died at cycle 28. Smelled burnt. Returned.
FAIL · Week 4
Unit E — hose connection leaked sporadically. Couldn't reproduce, but flooded twice in week 4. Returned.
MID · 6 weeks
Unit F — survived 54 cycles but rust appeared inside drum at week 5. Cosmetic, but not a long-term keeper.
MID · 6 weeks
Unit G — 73% water removal on spin (we wanted 80%+). Clothes took 4+ hours to air-dry vs 90 minutes on the survivors.
PASS · 6 weeks
Unit H — solid performer. 81% water removal, 47 dB wash, 67 dB spin. We took 6 more units to extended testing.
PASS · 200 cycles
Unit I (became Tide) — 81% water removal, 45 dB wash, 65 dB spin. Hit cycle 200 with no rust, no shake, no smell. The seal was still flat. We bought 3 more from different batches and they all behaved identically.

11%

Pass rate · 1 of 9 made the cut

What we learned about mini washers

  • Spin matters more than wash. Every unit washed clothes acceptably. The difference was how dry they came out — 60% vs 80% water removal is the difference between 4 hours and 90 minutes of air-dry.
  • Plastic smell tells you everything. If it smells in week 1, it'll smell in year 1. We don't ship anything that smells.
  • Noise is mostly the spin cycle. Wash motors are quiet on every unit. Spin motors range from 65 to 80 dB — that's the difference between "neighbor doesn't notice" and "neighbor calls the building manager."
  • Seal quality is the long-term story. Cheap rubber compresses unevenly after ~50 cycles and leaks. Tide uses a thicker EPDM seal that costs us $0.80 more per unit. Worth it.
"Reviews lie about cycle 30. Nobody writes a 5-star review at cycle 200, because by then they've moved on. We watched cycle 200."

What we'd test again

Cycle counts up to 500 (1 year of normal use). Cold-room performance (in a closet that hits 50°F in winter). Mineral buildup with NYC tap water (very hard) over 6 months. We're running these tests now — we'll publish results in Q3 2026.

The transparency note

We don't publish the names of the 8 units that didn't make it. Not because we want to protect them — they make a real impact on people's apartments — but because product runs change and a Unit D from last quarter may be a different machine today. We'd rather you trust our process than memorize a brand-shaming list.

If you're shopping mini washers and want our raw notes (anonymized), email support@ceenor.com. We'll send the spreadsheet.

0 comments

— More from the Journal

May 16 · 2 min

Laundromat math: $874 you'll never see again

May 16 · 2 min

The hot water physics of an apartment